I ended up having the guts to buy the Biore one only because of two people, Bunny and ShuAddict.
Bad smudgy picture :D
One reason why I smudge so bad in the above picture is because I used the Victoria Secret Very Sexy Gel eyeliner duo. I had bad experience with it the first time about a year ago and tried to use it again and it's still as bad. Smudges terribly, not much lasting power, goes MIA in a few hours, turns grey etc.